Coffee Wars: Starbucks Moves into Alcohol

Starbuck’s (NASDAQ:SBUX) is testing serving alcohol at a couple of locations, to try out the idea as a way for increasing the later daypart business. Curiously, they are changing the name of the first outlet to “15th Ave. Coffee & Tea, inspired by Starbucks.” I guess the question remains what has been posed before; how badly do you need to beat a brand to destroy it from the inside?

Are Instant Coffee and Alcohol Brand Builders?

While the expansion of business in a weaker time period is always a bonus, there seems to be less respect for the core brand within Starbuck’s than there is from the outside. First, the instant coffee brand -VIA™ rollout, and now trying to be a limited-option bar in the evening.

Not Addressing Menu Overhaul

Actually the alcohol idea isn’t a bad one, but it would make more sense to include it as an overall remaking of the Starbuck’s menu. They seem to be running from the challenge being put forth by the QSR’s, McDonalds (NYSE:MCD) and Dunkin Donuts (Private), in particular, but all the big chains are jumping on the coffee bandwagon.

The way to get solid revenue increases driving at Starbucks is to commit to providing a viable light meal option to complement the beverage business, and this is something they seem reluctant to do. If Starbucks can’t drive revenue by coming up with a way make going there about more than just a side pastry or cookie, they lose the revenue war to the QSR’s challenge in the long run.

Fast Food Chains Challenging on Coffee

While Starbucks doesn’t need a “Dollar Menu” or to put french fryers in, a feature deli-style sandwich that goes with either a cold coffee drink or the newly-introduced beer or wine would seem to be a smart positioning move, and give them a chance at increasing per-ticket rings and putting more revenue into the later dayparts they are trying to improve.

Starbuck’s is running from what made it a premier brand ands a ubiquitous presence in all but the smallest of markets.

When you have a big ship to steer, you can’t do it with a gentle push, you need to give it a good shove. The QSR’s have issued a challenge to Starbucks, if they don’t make a solid move in response to come up with a light meal alternative, they will lose the revenue war down the road.